Re: Least deserving nominations
Dr. Lecter wrote:
What nominations this year are the least deserving ones, in your opinion?
These are my picks:
1. Shark Tale for Best Animated Feature - C'mon, seriously...
2. Taylor Hackford for Best Director - He was good, but certainly not THAT good, directors like Michael Mann or Mike Nichols deserved it more this year
3. Ray for Best Picture - Ray was a good movie, but it was carried solely by Jamie Foxx. Many films (like Kill Bill Vol. 2 and Eternal Sunshine) last year were much better.
Let us hear your picks.
Agree with 1 and 2 but not 3. While I think many pics were better than Ray (for instance, all the other Golden Globes Best Comedy/Musical nominees), it was still a better bio-pic than either The Aviator or Finding Neverland. At the very least, Finding Neverland should be replaced first before Ray.
This year a lot of my expected undeserved nominees were actually snubbed, so I'm pretty happy.
But some undeserved nominations for me:
Virginia Madsen in Sideways - She is pretty good, but doesn't really rise above the high calibre of the script/direction. So many different people could occupy the same role, and given the same dialogue, would have done just as good a job, if not better. The person who played Miles' ex-wife, as brief as she was, had much greater presence than Madsen.
Cate Blanchett in The Aviator - IMO, the worst part of the movie. With exception to the excellent family lunch scene, Blanchett dragged the movie down whenever she's there. Unlike all the other actors/actresses portraying real-life people this year, her's felt most like an exaggerated impersonation that felt completely ungenuine as a real person in Howard's life. Though part of the blame may lie with the screenwriter's fault, this performance is even more overrated than her turn in Elizabeth.
House of Flying Daggers' Cinematography - Christopher Doyle's work in Hero and Peter Pau's work in Crouching Tiger makes Xiaoding Zhao's job in Daggers looks like that of an amateur. It is a travesty that Daggers got in ahead of Collateral, The Motorcycle Diaries, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events, etc.